Game Reviews

Top 5 Story Games Where Your Choices Really Matter

If you are anything like me, you love a good game where the story really shines. I have formed a strong connection with many game characters, having had the pleasure to watch them grow, while experiencing heartbreak during their untimely deaths.

Story-driven games have become a personal favorite of mine. There is nothing more thrilling than having the power of things in your hands. With high stakes, one wrong move could mean the death of a character! Many choices have had me on the edge of my seat, watching on in anticipation as I see how events unfold.

Today, I will be going over my list of five story-driven games where your choices have an adverse impact on the gameplay and narrative. Sit back and buckle your seatbelts, because we are in for a wild ride.

Detroit Become Human

What can I really say about this game? It is undoubtedly a masterpiece. Detroit: Become Human is set in the year of 2038, where androids have become a popular ‘product’ for humans. Some are being treated well, while others are being misused for selfish needs… With this, comes the rise of deviant androids! Deviants are androids that have developed their own personalities, acting just like an ordinary human that has rights.

There are 3 main protagonists in the game, which you have the opportunity to play as during different chapters. Each one has their own journey, and by the end of the game, their stories all come together as a whole. I really like the dialogue and relationship system in this game. However you choose to respond to other characters influences their opinion of you. This can unlock new story paths and ultimately result in different endings. Believe me when I say that every single choice you make matters. Imagine my shock when I was being careless and actually got one of the protagonists killed early on!

Life is Strange

Life is Strange is a wonderfully written episodic game. Max finds out that she has the power to reverse time; with this knowledge, she decides to alter events and make crucial decisions. We have all probably thought about being in her shoes honestly!

I think the reversing time mechanic is really unique. This really gives us a sense of control, as we have to rely on our memory and strategy to make good decisions. The shy personality of Max contrasts really well with Chloe, her punk best friend that loves taking risks.

From uncovering a murder mystery to figuring out who is the mastermind behind it all, this game is a rollercoaster of emotions. A lot of thought goes into all these narrative branches and gameplay, so it is really refreshing to see how everything unfolds. Without spoiling anything, the ending decision had me crying my eyes out. Unfortunately, things aren’t that simple and we soon have a full-on natural disaster on our hands. Can you truly avoid fate?

Until Dawn

Until Dawn is a horror interactive game. After a shocking incident where two sisters ended up dying, a group of friends stays at the same place sometime later, isolated from the rest of civilization as strange things begin happening. A masked killer is on the loose, tormenting the group by setting up traps and subjecting them to sick games.

As if this wasn’t bad enough, there are also Wendigos on the loose ‒ a ghastly creature that is attracted to movement, eating humans and tearing off limbs in the process. The game focuses on the ‘butterfly effect’, which is the concept behind how your decisions have a long-lasting impact.

Each chapter is focused on a main character respectively. Depending on the choices you make and whether you succeed at quicktime events, dictates whether or not any character will actually die! Your consequences are permanent, and the entire story changes as the group adapts with potential deaths and situations. Beware, nature believes in karmic justice here.

The Walking Dead: The Telltale Series

I’m pretty sure that everyone knows about The Walking Dead. It’s a great show based on how people learn to survive in a zombie apocalypse. Telltale is known to be a company that creates story-driven games, so this is no exception!

The Walking Dead: The Telltale Series has four seasons. You start off with Lee, a proclaimed ‘criminal’ that meets Clementine, who is a girl he starts to take care of. Along the way, you really feel as though you are part of this post-apocalyptic world and are faced with tough decisions. When you meet new groups of people, will you choose to trust them or cast them away?

It’s amazing to grow up with these characters and see how they develop in this harsh world. There are many infamous situations where you can save one character while sacrificing the other… Trust will be broken, hearts will be crushed and people will be killed. Remember, always aim for the zombie’s head!

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

To end things off, we have The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. This is probably the most ‘advanced’ game on the list, because it is actually considered an RPG fighting game. Geralt, the main character, is known as ‘the Witcher’. He is essentially a monster slayer that acts like a bounty hunter, having been trained from a young age to slaughter beasts.

The fighting in this game has such a nice combat system, with stamina and a variety of spells you can use to defeat enemies. The open world is full of quests, charming villages and treacherous terrain There are many companions you can choose to embark with, each having their own benefits and respective backgrounds.

There are so many side missions you can take during the main campaign as well. It is so nice to see a game’s story be driven. If you don’t really like the ‘interactive movie’ feeling of the other games, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is the perfect mix of combat gameplay and extensive lore.


  1. All games that have dicision making and whenever you have a serious choice to make you look at your phone for answers you know its good because one mistake can give you the wrong ending

  2. You guys should also check out Greedfall. Though not everyone will like it as it is an Indie title with limited budget so the graphics wont meet your expectations but the story of that game is top notch and if you liked games such as Dragon age Origins and Witcher 2 then I’m sure you’ll like this one too….

  3. “Games Where Your Choices Really Matter” – why “Witcher 3”? xD Only because it is popular? In “Witcher” (1st game in serie) and “Witcher 2” was much more relations from choices. In W3 we can only choose a girl for Geralt, and have a stupid method of choices for final destiny of Ciri (imo; I just have no idea how snowball game can help her to survive in another world >.<). W3 is just a PRed almost linear game. In W2 we have 2 games in "1 box". In W1 was fractions and walkthrough and storyline was depend on the chosen fraction.
    Even "Mass Effect" has more choices (choices from ME1 can change events in ME3 !), maybe choices there do not change the game final (in W3 final also same, we can choose only what will happen with Ciri), but they deeper and makes the game much more replayable.
    I'm agree "Walking Dead" and "Life is Strange" – really amazing games; never played others 2 games; but "Winther 3" doesn't fit the category from the topic header 🙂
    Ofc, its just "imo" 😉
    "Tyranny" has many choices and at least 4 different playthroughs depended on choices. "Age of Decadence" too.

Back to top button